CBC story about Canadian sheep sent to Israel raises ethical, factual issues

sheep-1

A recent CBC story reported that these sheep have just come from Canada to Israel where they now live on a farm on land confiscated from Palestinian peasants in 1948. CBC’s Derek Stoffel seems to think this is a good news story. But his article has some major issues. Read more…

According to CBC journalist Derek Stoffel, a historic breed of sheep is now finally back in Israel, thanks to Canadians Jenna and Gil Lewinski of Abbotsford, B.C.

Stoffel reports that the link between the Lewinski’s flock and sheep which used to roam the middle east in biblical times has been established by reading… the bible.

“I thought they were novelty sheep, but it wasn’t until I took out my Bible and started researching that I was truly amazed,” Gil Lewinski was quoted as saying.

It isn’t shocking to know that some people take the Bible literally. But it is rather surprising that a CBC journalist would do so.

The Old Testament book of Genesis says the patriarch Jacob bred speckled and spotted varieties to produce sheep that are white with dark patches and have up to six horns“, helpfully adds CBC journalist Stoffel, seemingly verifying Lewinski’s conclusion.

In addition to verifying whether CBC considers the Bible as a reliable source of historical information, CBC’s research department might also want to check out another aspect of Stoffel’s story.

2017-03-14 (2)According to Stoffel, the sheep have been brought to a farm in the Israeli agricultural town of Nes Harim, west of Jerusalem.

Nes Harim has a dark history.

It is an Israeli “moshav” (a kind of collective farm) created on confiscated Palestinian land after the local inhabitants were driven out of a Palestinian village.

According to Wikipedia, “After a military assault on Bayt ʿIṭāb by Israeli forces in October 1948, the village was depopulated and demolished. Many of the villagers had fled to refugee camps in the West Bank less than 20 kilometres (12 mi) from the village. In 1950, an Israeli moshav, Nes Harim, was established north of the built up portion of Bayt ‘Itab, on an adjacent peak. Meanwhile, the Jewish National Fund established a park over the ruins of Bayt ‘Itab and surrounding villages, in a deliberate attempt to erase their very existence – an act echoed nearly 20 years later by the JNF’s Canada Park.

It is not clear whether Mr. Stoffel knows about the dark history of the Moshav. But it would be reasonable to expect a Canadian journalist to have at least a passing interest Israel’s recent history. After all, its a lot easier to prove that Nes Harim was established on the remains of a Palestinian village destroyed 70 years ago than to use the bible to prove that sheep from Abbotsford actually came from the middle east over 2000 years ago.

___________________________________________

Canada Talks Israel Palestine (CTIP) aims to promote a serious discussion in Canada about the complicated and emotional Israel/Palestine issue. If you support our educational mission, why not join? Or make a donation? Or learn more about what we do?  Contact us at: membership.ctip@gmail.com.

 

 

 

7 comments

  1. Peter.
    Bravo. All part of the normalization of the occupation

    Paul@heinbecker.ca
    http://www.heinbecker.ca
    613 853 2761

    Principal, Paul Heinbecker and Associates, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
    Distinguished Fellow, Centre for International Governance Innovation, and
    Fellow, Balsillie School of International Relations, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada

    1. Today, a lot of focus is on “the occupation” by which people usually mean lands taken over in 1967. But this story is about lands taken over in 1948. Their rightful owners are in refugee camps somewhere. No compensation has ever been paid. And CBC’s journalist, instead of uncovering and exposing this story, or even referring to it, colludes in covering it up.

  2. As a Canadian citizen I am appalled that Any Canadian business is aiding and abetting these zionist Terrorists. They torture children.. kidnap children. steal land. starve humans. How can anyone accept this behavior.??

  3. Bravo Sheila, voices like yours should be heard all over by all decent people. For how long Israeli crimes can be hidden and defended?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s