Amnesty International Canada “deeply concerned and disappointed” by Canada’s opposition to ICC investigation of potential Israeli war crimes – Alex Neve

AmnestyAlexNave_610px

Canada was one of the early and principled supporters of the idea of an International Criminal Court. But recently Canada has found a lamentably legalistic reason to undercut the ICC in its investigation of potential Israeli war crimes. See the video interview with Amnesty International Canada General Secretary Alex Neve. Read more….

“Canada played a crucial role in establishing the International Criminal Court,” proudly notes the official Global Affairs Canada (GAC) website. “It continues to support the ICC with crucial leadership, advocacy and resources.”

On the same page GAC continues, “Canada became the first country in the world to incorporate the obligations of the Rome Statute into its national laws when it adopted the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act on June 24, 2000.”

But Canada’s principled (and even somewhat boastful) statements don’t seem to apply, it seems, when the ICC wants to investigate potential war crimes by Israel, which Canada sees as an “ally”.

When Fatou Bensouda, Chief Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court announced on December 20th, 2019, that she was opening an investigation into potential Israeli war crimes in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip, human rights activists around the world had a common reaction — “Finally!”.

Predictably, Israel went into high gear to try to enlist the support of its friends around the world to help sideline the investigation. Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu even called Prime Minister Trudeau to ask for help.

A few days later, Trudeau, perhaps concerned about pressures from Canada’s pro-Israel lobby, informed the ICC that Canada would not support the investigation. The reason? Canada does not recognize Palestine as a state – notwithstanding the fact that 138 of 193 UN member countries do recognize the Palestinian State!! 

Canada’s long-standing position is that it does not recognize a Palestinian state.”, Guillaume Bérubé, a spokesperson for Global Affairs Canada, told Canadian Jewish news in an email. “In the absence of a Palestinian state, it is Canada’s view that the (ICC) does not have jurisdiction in this matter under international law,” Bérubé added.

Aware of these developments, on February 28th Alex Neve, Secretary General of the Canadian branch of Amnesty International and Professor Michael Lynk, UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in the Occupied Palestinian Territories sent an urgent joint letter to Prime Minister Trudeau and Foreign Minister Louis-Philipppe Champagne. In the letter they reviewed Israel’s history of human rights abuses and argued that Canada should actively support the work of the investigator.  (As of this date, no answer has been given to the letter.)

AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL ACCUSES TRUDEAU OF THREATENING THE ICC

“We are deeply concerned by news reports that (…) Canada, has “reminded the Court” of its provision of budgetary resources in a letter to the ICC (…) which appears to be a threat to withdraw financial support.”

Amnesty International, March 16, 2020

 

On May 7th, CTIP interviewed Amnesty International Canada Secretary General Alex Neve about the ICC investigation, and Canada’s role in it.

 

Amnesty International Canada is not the only organization calling on the Canadian government to reverse its position. By April 29th, 42 Canadian civil society organizations have signed a letter supporting the ICC investigation and urging the Canadian government to reverse its position. “The Canadian government has accountability through both international and domestic law to take steps to ensure Israel does not commit war crimes and is held accountable for war crimes it does commit.” the letter stated. Other organizations which agree are encouraged so sign it as well.

Anyone concerned about Canada’s reluctance to support the ICC could write a short note to Prime Minister Trudeau, and Foreign Affairs Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne, with a copy to their local MP, and… of course to their friends.

____________________________________________________________________________

Canada Talks Israel Palestine (CTIP) is the weekly newsletter of Peter Larson, Chair of the Ottawa Forum on Israel/Palestine (OFIP). It aims to promote a serious discussion in Canada about the complicated and emotional Israel/Palestine issue. There is no need to use strong words. A focus on the truth, clear analysis and human rights is enough. Readers who have a different point of view are invited to make comment. 

Want to learn more about what we do? Go to http://www.ottawaforumip.org.

Contact us at: ofip.chair@gmail.com.

7 comments

  1. And Canada is seeking a seat on the security council of the United Nations. Canada is not enduring it’s self to the world when it is out of step when it comes to human rights for the Palestinians.

  2. And already people everywhere are responding in ways that resonate with the universal human rights vision, through compassion, community and putting others first.

  3. It is disappointing that Canada has a chapter of the fake human rights organization Amnisty for Russia, China, and Syria International.

    1. Hey Jack, would you mind explaining further. Is it your opinion that Amnesty Canada is a “fake” human rights organization? Is Alex Neve not real? Did he not get the Order of Canada? What on earth are you talking about? Do you say AIC is a “fake” human rights organization because it criticizes Israel? Are all the other organizations, and countries that also criticize Israel “fake” organizations and even “fake” countries? Please share your thinking.

      1. As Amnesty International appears to disproportionately attack Israel over affairs that other states are far worse offenders, in proportion making Israel’s offences appear to be misdemeanors against humanity, aside from the fact that it took a month to condemn Hamas’ arrest of a peace activist, caused by an AI employee, is proof enough that human rights is not AI’s priority.

        When you post another condemnation from another NGO that masquerades as a human rights organization, I will comment at that time.

      2. Mr. Sigman, I think you should take a more careful look at the Amnesty Website. Israel is only one of many countries it denounces for its human rights abuses. In my view, perhaps it should pay more attention to Israel.

      3. Mr. Larson, I have taken a careful look. I do not see what taking a more careful look will accomplish. Regardless, their website is for public consumption. The condemnations that make the headlines is a greater indicator of AI’s immoral stance on human rights. Of course your view is that AI should pay more attention to Israel as a bastion of Human Rights in the Middle East; a liberal democratic oasis wherein the human rights of all of its citizens are protected and where there is no legal discrimination against its citizens for religion, sexual orientation, political thought, except for those who advocate for the total eradication of Arb presence in Israel, and the only flourishing vibrant Christian population in the Middle East.

        AI should pay attention and should lavish praise despite the few faults found in Israel as are found in most liberal democracies.

Comments are closed.