Is Gaza finished?: Personal impressions from a short visit

IMG_7110

The three punishing Israeli attacks on Gaza (2009, 2011, 2014) have had a serious impact on Gaza and its children. Hundreds killed, thousands more injured, whole neighbourhoods demolished, and tens of thousands suffering from the post-traumatic stress of seeing death and destruction around them.

But is Gaza finished? Are Gaza’s children ready to give up? Not from what I could see during a four day visit last month. See my report.

Instead of hopelessness, I found hopefulness. Instead of ignorance about the “outside world”, I found curiosity. Instead of a preoccupation with religion, I found a focus on finding a way to solve their predicament.

Does that mean that Gazan children are just the same as Canadian children? Well, no. They have been through pain that we would find hard to imagine. But despite that, youthful optimism bounces forward around every corner.

IMG_7124

V for “victory” or V for “peace”? – Street kids in the heavily-bombed out area of Shuja’iyya flash me their greeting

IMG_7064

First graders always love to wave to visitors. Will they be allowed to leave Gaza when they grow up?

My main objective in visiting Gaza was to check in on vocational training programs operated by the Near East Council of Churches (NECC) in Gaza, a partner of the United Church of Canada. These programs are designed to give practical training to adolescent boys and girls many of whom come from families that have been shattered by repeated Israeli bombing.  Unfortunately, there are many more applicants than the funding permits. “If we had more funding”, notes NECC’s Executive Director Dr. Issa Tarazi, “we could easily take in twice as many students.”

IMG_7261

Advanced Dressmaking course, one of several courses offered by NECC for young women

iug green campus

Students between classes at the Islamic University of Gaza, the oldest and largest university in Gaza. There are now 9 institutions of higher education in Gaza.

In addition to talking to people at the NECC vocational training centres, I also visited other educational institutions, including the Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), The University College of Applied Sciences (UCAS), and the American International School.

Over 4 days of formal meetings and private conversations, I was astounded to see just how eager and enthusiastic Gazan students are about learning, and how hopeful that things would improve in the future.

IMG_7083

Nervous but optimistic. Grade 10 students at the prestigious American International School. What does the future hold for them?

All the students I talked to were extremely frustrated by they call an unfair blockade imposed on Gaza by Israel. One young grad student told me that he had been awarded a scholarship to study in Spain, only to find that Israel would not allow him to go to Jordan to get his Spanish visa. So he had to put his dreams for future education on hold.

But after 4 days of talking to Gazan young people, I came away with a rather different overall impression than I had expected. They want the world to hear their voices, to understand their stories. They understand that they have been alternately ignored or demonized by the western media, and aim to overcome that through intelligent use of social media. They are learning English, French and other languages, and looking to make contact with the outside world.

IMG_7046

Gazan students were curious, intelligent and engaged. Ahmed (on the left) is one of the aspiring writers who has been published through the “We are not Numbers” project.

One interesting student-run project is called “We are not Numbers”, which has some European funding. It was created to allow Palestinian youths from Gaza (and now also from refugee camps in Lebanon) to reach out to the outside world. One of the students who has shared his dramatic personal story of tragic loss is Ahmed Alnaouq, whom I met in a café in Gaza City.

gaza writes backAnother project is called “Gaza writes back”, which has now published a book of compelling short stories written by young people about loss, drama and love and companionship.

I met Refaat Alareer, a lecturer of English Literature and creative writing at the Islamic University of Gaza and the editor of Gaza Writes Back in a coffee house near the university. He told me that he thinks that telling stories is both cathartic for the writer and also a way to allow outsiders to appreciate Gazan youth in a way they have not been able to before.

IMG_7248

Professor Alareer’s 4 story family house in the Gaza City neighbourhood of Suja’iyya was completely destroyed by Israeli bombs in 2014. His brother was killed. “All our memories were buried under the rubble”, he wrote in a recent post about the incident.

But Gazan youths are not only focused on getting their story “out”. They are also keenly interested in better understanding the outside world and have a number of projects aimed at helping them better understand the world in which they live.

IMG_7166

Maram, Abdel and Yousef at the Centre for Political and Development Studies

One these projects is called the Centre for Political and Development Studies (CPDS). CDPS has a well stocked library and organizes web-based seminars through which they hear presentations from people around the world including the USA and Europe. (A recent seminar was held with Norman Finkelstein).

Canadian Palestinian human rights activists sometimes tend to view Gazans only as victims. Which of course they are. Most of them are refugees from what is now Israel. They cannot return to Israel because they are not Jewish. If they were Jewish, of course, Israel would not only welcome them back, but give them automatic citizenship and even a “resettling allowance”.

But Gazans are not just victims. They are also actors. They are looking for a way to pry open the bars of their Israeli-imposed prison. We should help them.

 

 

 

11 comments

  1. Good account Peter. I’m most impressed by how systematically you contact and meet with individuals and organizations on the ground to form your impressions.

  2. Gazans are incredibly resilient, despite what they have suffered during the past almost five decades of Israeli occupation, and especially the years after the imposition of the blockade by Israel. As the late Dr. Iyad Sarraj (psychiatrist and founder of the Gaza Mental Health Center) said: Not only are our children traumatized, we are a traumatized nation. I have so much respect for the people of Gaza living in the world’s largest open air prison. It is now up to us, the international community to work for ending the blockade and supporting the development of the Gaza Strip so people can live. As we know, drinkable water is one of the most crucial issues.

  3. Thanks Peter. Well written. You didn’t mention the value of your solidarity in just visiting, which is so meaningful. Thanks for keeping a spotlight on Gaza.

    We are bringing a Gaza visitor on a cross-country tour in 2016 to continue to allow voices of Gaza to be heard here. We’ll look forward to working together.

  4. Thanks, Peter, Very helpful to challenge the stereotype of the victim which it would be too easy for us to rely on in trying to understand Gaza. Practical help, and more of it, is what we need to find ways to give.

  5. One very helpful thing we can all do is lobby the Liberal government to again fund UNRWA. UNRWA is in dire straits.

  6. Great work Peter. I’ll hope to get similar pics and narrative.Just bought the Gaza short stories book so will have a good read.

    Do you recall the name of the Canadian guy who several have mentioned who actually headed up UNWRA in Gaza??Wonder where he is now and if he would be a useful ally..??

    William

  7. A great look at Gaza beyond the stereotypes; we all need plans for the future and a trust in the children to carry on.

  8. 30 years ago I made my first visit to the Gaza strip. The Palestinians were occupying the largest refugee camp in the world, a prison camp in which they were and are trapped, robbed of their freedom. We treat the world the way we do and then wonder why we are faced with the consequences. Hopefully with the new Prime Minister we can offer more than guns, bombs and tepid pious rhetoric.

  9. Peter,
    Thank you for this window on the life of the people of Gaza, it keeps our hope that things will turn better hopefully sooner than later.

  10. With the world focused on climate change, I am disappointed that there is any tolerance for wars, destruction, and the wastage of resources (including human resources). We need to put an end to any enabling of these human rights violations and focus on the greater good of peace and prosperity for all.

Comments are closed.